I really liked the illustrations. He solved the problem and helped pig. It was a nice book.

This book was very good. It kept me intrigued the whole time. i had heard people say it had a dramatic and unexpected ending so that kept my interest and made me speed through the book so i could see what the ending was and it was very unexpected. the ending took a turn and when i found out her friends had been dead the whole time and she was just hallucinating that her friends were there, blew. my. mind. it made me super sad though so i honestly cant tell if i loved the book or didnt like it in the end. (:

While this started out a little on the slower side, the build up and ending were quite exciting! A merging of witchcraft, nautical adventures, romance and girl power! I love Sarah Penner as an author and this book was no exception. Three stars for the "slow start" but overall a fun read!

I didn’t like it because I don’t like Elmo, but my 2-year old brother loves it

Swyler's writing surpasses her first book. This is a beautiful story, well told, poignant. The main protagonist is an eleven year old girl, Nedda, smart and ambitious. She desires to reach the stars. It is also a story of love, loss, and discovery. It's classified as fiction, yet the story opens in space on board a module traveling to a new planet. The science--chemistry and physics--are not overwhelming and are important to the story. This is a book I would read again.

I’m excited to read the sequel

Great for early readers.

Just love the characters how much they go through just keeps you wanting more

Eilah sat through the entire book ??

Loved the pictures in the book loved the flow of the story easy for them to fallow along